The Original NY Pizza

The Original NY Pizza anchors the Holly Springs Crossings center with a convenient stop for classic slices and pies. Founded in 1991, the homegrown brand still leans on its New York roots while serving families across Western Wake. Loyal guests know they can pop in for a quick bite or call ahead for a hot pie right off the stone deck.

Premium Wisconsin cheese, freshly packed Italian tomatoes, and dough made in house daily keep every order rooted in the restaurant’s original promise. The menu spans thin-crust New York pies, square-cut Sicilian pans, laden stromboli, and the signature Panetto that melds a pressed panini with a baked stromboli. Specialty combinations such as Buffalo chicken, white garden, and meat supreme join build-your-own options for slices or whole pies sized for any appetite.

Guests can order online for pickup or schedule delivery straight from the ovens, a convenience the team has long emphasized for Western Wake commuters. The Holly Springs Crossings address keeps it handy for weeknight dinners, team celebrations, and neighborhood gatherings without a trip into Cary. Backed by multiple Maggy Awards from Cary Magazine, this outpost continues to fly the flag for authentic New York-style pizza in the Triangle.