The Original N.Y. Pizza

The Original N.Y. Pizza anchors the Wellington Park center on Tryon Road with a decades-long legacy of Maggy Award-winning pies that bring New York flavor to Cary. Premium Wisconsin cheese, freshly packed Italian tomatoes, and dough made in-house daily keep the slices crisp yet foldable, delivering the classic combination regulars have trusted since the shop opened in 1991.

The Wellington Park menu spans hand-tossed rounds, Sicilian squares, stuffed pies, calzones, strombolis, and the signature Panetto pizza wraps, all offered alongside individual cheese, Sicilian, and stuffed slices for quick cravings. Whether you build a cheesesteak specialty pie or split a veggie supreme with friends, the kitchen leans on fresh vegetables and house recipes to maintain consistent flavor.

Guests can settle in for lunch or dinner, grab takeout, or schedule delivery, making this slice-focused shop a convenient stop for families, teams, and office catering alike. Its casual setup suits weeknight suppers as well as post-game celebrations, while the ability to mix whole pies with by-the-slice orders keeps everyone satisfied.