J&S New York Pizza

J&S New York Pizza anchors downtown Fuquay-Varina with a Cammarata family legacy dating to 1995, and this Varina dining room has welcomed neighbors since 2007. Siblings Phil Cammarata, Lori Shaver, and Ven Cammarata keep their father Silvio’s recipes alive, handing guests a slice of New York nostalgia in a warm, family-centered setting.

The menu leans into thin-crust pies, including Phil’s beloved Garbage Pizza stacked with sausage, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. House-made classics such as Josephine’s lasagna, garlic knots, chicken wings, and hearty subs round out the board, while freshly filled calzones and stuffed pizzas showcase the kitchen’s Sicilian roots.

Dine-in tables and a relaxed patio invite lingering with friends, yet the counter moves swiftly for takeout orders, and drivers deliver within a six-mile radius to keep regulars stocked on game night. Whether guests are craving a quick slice or a family feast with pasta and salad, J&S stays focused on scratch-made comfort and personable service.